How to Conduct an EHR Vendor Selection: Scorecards, Demos, and References
3 min read
Choosing an Electronic Health Record (EHR) system is one of the most significant technology decisions a clinic or hospital can make. A clear EHR vendor selection process ensures that the choice aligns with actual workflows rather than being influenced by sales presentations.
This article outlines three essential tools that can make the EHR vendor selection process more objective: a weighted evaluation scorecard, scripted demos, and structured reference checks.
EHR Vendor Selection Starts With a Weighted Scorecard
A scorecard transforms subjective opinions into comparable metrics. Start by identifying the criteria that are most important to your organization.
Common categories include usability, interoperability, vendor support, security, and cost. Assign a weight to each criterion to reflect the priorities of your clinicians and executives.
Name the stakeholders who will evaluate each vendor.
Define must-have and nice-to-have features.
Assign weights that total 100 percent.
Score every vendor using the same scale.
Run Scripted Demos Instead of Vendor-Led Tours
Vendor-led demonstrations often showcase the best aspects of a product, while scripted demos illustrate how the system performs in your daily operations.
Provide each vendor with the same scenarios, such as patient registration, medication ordering, or referrals. Request that they complete these tasks live, allowing clinical staff to observe and rate each demonstration.
Scoring immediately after each session keeps feedback fresh and prevents dominant voices from swaying the evaluations. Our EHR selection services utilize this same methodology with clients.
Check References the Right Way
References can reveal insights that a demo cannot provide. Request references from organizations of similar size and specialty that have implemented the system within the last two years.
Inquire about the go-live experience, the responsiveness of support, and what they would negotiate differently if given the chance. The Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT also offers valuable guidance on health IT and certification.
How well did the vendor support your implementation?
What surprised you after the go-live?
Would you choose the same system again?
Bring Stakeholders Into the Decision
The selection process is most effective when clinical, administrative, and IT leaders are all included. A small selection committee helps maintain momentum in decision-making.
Involving stakeholders early fosters trust. Individuals who participate in the selection process are more likely to support and adopt the system.
Conclusion
A structured EHR vendor selection process minimizes risk and safeguards patient care. Utilizing a weighted scorecard, scripted demos, and thorough reference checks equips your team with the evidence needed to make informed decisions.
Once you have selected a system, our EHR implementation team can assist you in planning the go-live. The Joxel Group is here to support your EHR vendor selection from start to finish.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an EHR evaluation scorecard?
An EHR evaluation scorecard is a weighted checklist used to compare EHR vendors against specific criteria, aiding teams in making objective decisions.
Why use scripted demos?
Scripted demos ensure that every vendor demonstrates the same real-world workflows, making comparisons fairer.
How many references should we check?
It is advisable to check at least three references from organizations similar to yours, including one that has experienced challenges.
Who should be on the selection committee?
The selection committee should include clinicians, administrators, IT professionals, and revenue cycle leaders. Diverse input leads to better adoption of the chosen system.
6 min read Healthcare data migration planning is essential for organizations aiming to transition legacy records into a new system without compromising…